The Predators Among Us

Disclaimer: Due to mature content, reader discretion advised.


Lost Ground: Looking Back

There is something from my past that has remained secret, except to those closest to me. This personal story has been the root of every failed relationship and romantic pursuit in which I have participated. Where did I go wrong? What is this shortcoming I am trying ameliorate? These are the questions I ask myself on the regular… for the past 18 years, I have been posing these questions. The answer I have finally come to is… it wasn’t me that messed up. I was there, and I was a participant– but I didn’t make the choice. I was convinced it was me, even though numerous therapists and friends reassured me that it wasn’t. The story goes like this…

night caller claw

The Monster in My Closet

When I was in high school in rural Minnesota, I was an overachiever. This manifested in hyper-involvement in extracurricular activities, as well as doing just enough at an adequate level to get good grades. I was on statewide advisory committees; I was the captain of a couple after school teams; I was friendly enough with everyone in order to give the illusion of popularity and give others the sense that I had a plethora of friends. In truth, I did not have popularity, nor many friends. My only true friends, looking back, were older and graduated 1 to 3 years ahead of me. No one seemed wise to this fact as I found survival in the facade of happiness… no one, save one person. There was a teacher in my school who seemed to see through my charade. Little did I know that he had been observing me for some time, picking up my patterns, my loneliness, and ultimately my unhappiness.


Frank was the choir teacher and music director who, for years, did not give me the time of day. He was that teacher and coach who befriended the popular kids, the same kids who were stars of the wrestling and football teams, both of which he served as a coach. Since I was not in choir or on either of those teams, I spent years trying to gain his favor since he was the musical director for the musicals, and of course, I was in every one of those. I was not sure why I wanted him to take note of me outside of the theater, other than he seemed to really like those boys he interacted with on a daily basis and it appeared that they liked him and shared a special connection. I guess I longed for closeness with another male desperately, and when Frank was with those boys, I saw them laugh and have a good time. I thought I could look forward to that if I ever became close to him.

Finally, when I was 16 years old and a junior in high school, I lost some of my baby weight and started to molt the skin of my awkward years, not all of it, but enough for people to notice– or at least one person noticed. It was then that Frank started to notice me. Its genesis was close to what I expected, friendly, jovial laughter, but soon there after, the interactions started to shift. Our conversations grew more quiet and insular. He invited me to his office before school. He started to ask me questions about my personal life and inquired as to whom I was dating and whom I would like to date. I told him I was dating no one and gave some generic answers, to which he responded,

“Come on. I know who you are. You can tell me the truth.”

Having mastered the art of deferring my truth as a means of self-preservation in a small town, I did not indicate that I knew where his line of questioning was leading, nor was I about to admit anything to him as I did not know his intentions. I played dumb and my responses were of the same nature. He insisted, re-doubling his efforts to get me to confess a dark secret. I disappointed him that day, leaving his office, uncertain of why he was so adamant. Our visits became more regular, and every once in a while he would ask again if I wanted to tell him anything. I didn’t, so I left and would begin my day.

Frank was also the coach of the Quiz Bowl team and I was the captain. Frank and I were often in the front seat of a school van that he drove and the rest of our team sat in the back, joking and talking loudly while Frank would have whispered conversations with with me. One day in particular, I remember him turning to me in the van, as we were speeding down a countryside highway, he said,

“I see the way you look at me. It’s different than how the other boys do.”

 What was he talking about? In that moment, I began second guessing every interaction I ever had with him. In those moments, I thought, “No. I don’t. I don’t look at him differently. I have no clue what he is talking about.” 

This kind of commentary continued, and soon he started inviting me to his office before school started in the morning or after school before I went home or to my practice du jour. I was never in the high school choir, but I was involved in the musical productions, of which he also worked on, so I thought it would be about the upcoming show. The odd thing was when he asked me to wear sweat shorts to this meeting. I asked why… and he just played it off. I complied the next day, and I went into his office, wearing the sweat shorts that he requested. Looking back, I am not sure why I complied with this request, but I felt under his spell– his power. I don’t know what I thought would happen if I didn’t show up, or if I didn’t wear the shorts, but it felt like I had no option.

The red, athletic shorts

Soon after arriving to his office that morning, his reasoning for my choice of attire became evident. He told me to take a seat across from his desk, in the chair against the wall. As I crossed from the door to the chair, his eyes were locked on me, watching my every step. When I reached the destination, I dropped my backpack and say in the ratty old chair: the fabric had holes and the foam in the seat was revealing itself. I didn’t realize that I would soon be in the same vulnerable position.

I sat, initially only granting eye contact to the floor. My eyes gazed over my bare knees, catching the hems of the red gym shorts on the way. Silence filled the room, until finally,

“You came,” he said calmly, with a hint of surprise in his voice.

My brow furrowed and began to dig the trench near my eyebrows that exists today. “Of course I came. You asked me to…” This felt like a trick. “Was I not supposed to come?” His response was calm and measured, if not a bit groggy from the early nature of our “appointment.”

“Why did you ask me to meet with you this morning?” I couldn’t figure out why I was there, and he gave no indication as to why we were there. He continued to stare at me, half smile plastered on his face.

“I just want to talk. I think you and I have things to talk about.” The implication was thick in his tone, but the implication of what, I didn’t know. I knew what he wanted me to say, but I dared not say it. I was not ready to declare my sexuality. But I don’t think that’s what he wanted me to say. Falling in love with him was not anywhere near the truth that I knew, and I was not about to admit a falsehood, so I played dumb, “What do you mean? What do we have to talk about?”

He looked at me through his thick eyebrows with head tilted down. It was a look of displeasure and judgment. He held his gaze on me until I turned bright red with discomfort, smiled uncomfortably, and fidgeted in my chair, eventually landing on arms and legs crossed, ankle on knee. As soon as I found this posture, he said, “Ohhhh,” indicating a pleasurable surprise. Unsure of what provoked this reaction, I asked Frank what was the matter. He didn’t say anything. He simply met my gaze, and then looked down at my legs, specifically between my legs. I quickly caught on and adjusted my pose, apologizing for my unintentional reveal.

At that moment, his reason for wanting me in his office, alone and early in the morning, became crystal clear. He was not bothered in the slightest by leg crossing; instead, to my surprise, he was… delighted.

Frank directed, “Put your leg back up. It’s ok.” I felt strange about complying, but I figured he was a director of the shows I want to be in, so I didn’t want to upset him or give him reason not to treat me as one of his favorites. I recrossed my legs. His eyes remained on my crotch until he looked me in the eyes, my breath shallow and heart racing. He asked me what lies beyond the fabric of my Hanes. No one had ever talked to me about such intimate anatomy, and as a result, I noticed a stirring in my shorts– not because I was sexually excited, but because I was a teenager and getting attention.

The Genesis of Dysfunction

That is where it started– in the choir room office, before school, with a man over 2 times my age when I was no more than 16 years old.

Frank became more brazen with his requests, asking me to meet him in different rooms throughout the school; he asked me to perform in different ways; our interactions became more involved, and all the while, I was convinced this was how I had to be– secretive, shameful and therefore silent about the encounters, and protective of this man who told me time and time again that he was doing me a favor and that he cared for me.

In retrospect, tracing the timeline from that first moment in Frank’s office to now, I would never define his intention as favorable. Knowing what I have struggled with over the past 18 years– from addiction to eating issues to dishonesty and alienation– Frank knocked over a domino of self-destruction for me. That morning nearly two decades ago set into action a trajectory of which I never dreamed. Let’s recap: going to college and getting only mediocre grades; alcoholism; drug addition; getting kicked out of nursing school; fiscal mismanagement and failure; failure to thrive with unspeakable levels of privilege; a trail of wounded hearts due to my insensitivity and calloused detachment.

I became a stranger to my family, friends, and what’s more, I became a stranger to myself. I looked in the mirror and saw someone I hated. Frank helped me get there, but he didn’t do it alone. The abandonment I felt when I went to college also contributed to it– granted it was abandonment by a predator whom convinced me I was more than just a pawn in his sick game of deception. He used me and I reacted. And I reacted. And I reacted.

Last I heard of Frank, he resigned from an education job in Southern Minnesota. I called the district to find out the terms of his resignation, they wouldn’t tell me anything. There were moments of anger, rage, revenge. I consulted a lawyer; I thought about pursuing formal charges against him. By the time I was finally ready to confront the feelings and felt I was ready to take on the beast, too much time passed and I was outside the statute of limitations. I considered finding his home, driving to him, convincing him I wanted to rekindle our relationship, and either hurting him or killing him. These thoughts actually crossed my mind. The rage one must feel to murder someone is palpable for me, but it takes follow through– and that is the tough part. I had vivid fantasies of how I would have done it– it was Dexter meets Hannibal, minus the eating of flesh and brains. These are sentiments I never dreamed possible before my coming of age was interrupted and my first sexual experience was with a morbidly obese predator. These thoughts linger, always present and never realized.

Coming face to face with Frank is something I have imagined, and unlike the fantasies I had about hurting and ending his life, I could not imagine beyond the moment of standing in front of him, shallow breath and racing heart returning. The time of seeing him in person again is absent of any emotion, a blank space in my mind that leaves room for the possibility of any outcome. For that reason, I hope to never come face to face with the monster, Frank, again.

I have many hopes for him. I hope he is suffering in his own, isolated way. I hope he is lonely. I hope the people that used to call him friend, mentor, teacher, director– I hope they know the truth; that they know him for what he really is. A predator.

But most of all, more than any of the above wishes, I hope Frank doesn’t have access to youth anymore, and that I was the last in his trail of abuse and manipulation. Sadly, I doubt that was the case.

I wish I had known better at the time– for the sake of those who followed in my path, the unknowing young minds (and bodies) that Frank would inevitably meet.


25 thoughts on “The Predators Among Us”

  1. wow, nate. this is so intense, emotional, honest and raw. you go, girl. so very proud of you! i won’t pretend to imagine how awful such early experiences could have been, but the person who is climbing out of all that yuck is beautiful and real.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Nate. Oh my god. I am so sorry. We should have known the extent of this and helped you. I feel so bad and I am so glad to see where you are and who you are today. You are a warrior. We love you so much.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Pat. Pat. Pat. There was no one that could have helped me at the time– no one is to blame except for Frank. I honed my acting abilities surrounding that situation, for better or worse. You and Dale could not have known the extent, and there is no sense being hard on yourselves. My reasons for writing this was not to call out those who were in my life at the time and accuse them of letting this happen. That was most definitely not even a possibility. Smoke and mirrors everywhere. Deception is real, and hindsight is 20/20. xo


    2. Dear sweet Nate….I cried reading this blog and felt somewhat guilty as I questioned what was going on with you and the “creep” whe I was in In the school.. I wish we could have done something for you! You were always my favorite student and loved spending time with you laughing and taking you and other kids out of school to attend lyceums and events at other schools. I hope you are doing well and hope the next time you meet with the Neuch’s I could tag along…with pleasant thoughts and good memories of you…my favorite student! Joyce Halstrom. (


  3. The lives we live and the destruction we wreak (mainly on ourselves). Thank you for your story. I have several starting when I was about 8. I wrote one up and it was published in a book called I Never Told Anyone (Anybody???). It does help to tell the stories. Love you.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I am so proud of you for telling your story! I have been through a similar situation although I was 4 and didn’t know what was going on! I have noticed that it helped when I was able to talk about it and I still do! I’m so sorry this happened to you! I Can tell u that one do see the person who did this to me quite a bit and I’m not gonna lie… It’s not easy! Please let me know if you need anything!


  5. Oh My Goodness Nate! I am so sorry! Thank you for writing this and bringing an awareness. I never did much care for Frank in high school because he just made me feel very uncomfortable. I am so sorry that this had to happen to you and even more sorry about the pain that you have had since and will forever. However, you are such a great, beautiful man now and you are always a pleasure to follow on any social media network. Continue to be strong!


  6. I as a survivor of a predator, had been a victim for 2-3years (subconsciously blocked out time frame-very tramatic) at age 13 (thrown into a foster home-parents getting divorced.) I want to say to all the predators in this world that you all have NO IDEA of what damage you cause to your victims/survivors (life long damage.) I am a survivor because after I finally got the GUTS to run away from that foster home and I got a hold of booze , oh man did I have a place to hide then. Everytime I got drunk it was a suicide trip, and one time it worked, I was clinically dead, and THANK GOD’S GOOD GRACE, and the team at the ER, that brought me back. Now I live my life with the good Lord, and I’m pretty much happy, I say pretty much, because I still battle with the trama. One of my regular routines is reading my Bible everyday, and it seems there is always new things that I didn’t catch the last time I read it. I find comfort in reading my Bible. Take Care. Try reading the Bible for your comfort.


  7. Nathan. Sorry you went through all this. Sorry that you are still confronted with fallout. It is my sincere wish that you find a way to integrate/open to your vulnerable self and find intimacy and love in a partner. Certainly many of us have felt intimate and loving towards you. I hope that you are/were able to receive our affections and if not, do the necessary work to make this happen. It is my belief that being whole and healed is more than possible, but probable once we really attune. In all likehood, this beast had similar things done to him. Once you own your anger and compassion fully, you’ll see and feel what a large heart you have, able to contain all that is broken, and all that is luminous. You’re a role model. And a kind friend. And for all that was done to you, in your trusting sensitive heart, you never became a similar monster. Thanks for all that you have done for Benjamin, over time. I will never forget that you took him to gay pride as a pre-schooler and made him the all-inclusive thinker that he is. Peace.


  8. Rest assured this person will get what is coming to him in this life or the next.

    Nate you are a leader and a great person. Being a grade below you, I always looked up to you as a role model. Be strong and be well my friend.


    Liked by 1 person

  9. Dear Nate,
    I’ve read your story with tears welling up in my eyes. The comments of support for you have triggered more emotion and I wonder how you survived this ongoing ordeal. It surely speaks to your strength and resiliency, the strength of your character and the love of friends who shared your path in life. I cannot begin to imagine what pain and self doubt you have suffered but know that you have confronted the monster and his power to wreak havoc in your life will lessen and lessen over time. We thank you for having the courage to share this with the world or at least the world of FaceBook. This story is now on my timeline and I will alert others to it. Your bravery in telling your sad, sad tale will reap benefits in the lives of unknown children who may be saved from a predator because of your story. Know that we love you and support you and look forward to following your unfolding story in New York on FaceBook. We also have 2 nieces in New York City who would love to meet you. We wish you much success and happiness in your new life. Love, Joe and Carol Timmins.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s